Current:Home > MyVatican defends wartime Pope Pius XII as conference honors Israeli victims of Hamas incursion-LoTradeCoin
Vatican defends wartime Pope Pius XII as conference honors Israeli victims of Hamas incursion
View Date:2024-12-23 21:09:36
ROME (AP) — The Vatican secretary of state on Monday strongly defended World War II-era Pope Pius XII as a friend of the Jews as he opened an historic conference on newly opened archives that featured even Holy See historians acknowledging that anti-Jewish prejudice informed Pius’ silence in the face of the Holocaust.
Cardinal Pietro Parolin’s defensive remarks were delivered before the conference observed a minute of silence to honor victims of the Hamas incursion in Israel. Standing alongside the chief rabbi of Rome, Parolin expressed solidarity with the Israeli victims and “to those who are missing and kidnapped and now in grave danger.”
He said the Vatican was following the war with grave concern, and noted that many Palestinians in Gaza were also losing their lives.
The conference at the Pontifical Gregorian University was remarkable because of its unprecedented high-level, Catholic-Jewish organizers and sponsors: The Holy See, Israel’s Yad Vashem Holocaust research institute, the U.S. Holocaust Memorial Museum, the U.S. and Israeli embassies to the Holy See and Italy’s Jewish community.
The focus was on the research that has emerged in the three years since the Vatican, on orders from Pope Francis, opened the Pius pontificate archives ahead of schedule to respond to historians’ requests for access to the Holy See’s documentation to better understand Pius’ wartime legacy.
Historians have long been divided about Pius’ record, with supporters insisting he used quiet diplomacy to save Jewish lives and critics saying he remained silent as the Holocaust raged. The debate over his legacy has stalled his beatification campaign.
Parolin toed the Vatican’s longstanding institutional defense of the wartime pope, citing previously known interventions by the Vatican secretariat of state in 1916 and 1919 to American Jews that referred to the Jewish people as “our brethren.”
“Thanks to the recent opening of the archives, it has become more evident that Pope Pius XII followed both the path of diplomacy and that of undercover resistance,” Parolin said. “This strategic decision wasn’t an apathetic inaction but one that was extremely risky for everyone involved.”
After he left, however, other historians took the floor and offered a far different assessment of both Pius and the people in the Vatican who were advising him. They cited the new documents as helpful to understanding Pius’ fears, anti-Jewish prejudices and the Vatican’s tradition of diplomatic neutrality that informed Pius’ decisions to repeatedly keep silent even as individual Catholic religious orders in Rome sheltered Jews.
Giovanni Coco, a researcher in the Vatican Apostolic Archives who recently uncovered evidence that Pius knew well that Jews were being sent to death camps in 1942, noted that Pius only spoke of the “extermination” of Jews once in public, in 1943. The word was never again uttered in public by a pontiff until St. John Paul II visited Auschwitz in 1979.
Even after the war, Coco said, “in the Roman Curia the anti-Jewish prejudice was diffuse,” and even turned into flat-out antisemitism in the case of Pius’ top adviser on Jewish affairs, Monsignor Angelo Dell’Acqua.
David Kertzer, a Brown University anthropologist, cited several cases in which Dell’Acqua advised Pius against any public denunciation of the slaughter of European Jews or any official protest with German authorities about the 1943 roundup of Italy’s Jews, including “non-Aryan Catholics,” during the German occupation.
Kertzer said while Pius “personally deplored” the German efforts to murder Italy’s Jews, his overall priority was to “maintain good relations with the occupying forces.”
Rabbi Riccardo Di Segni, the chief rabbi of Rome, said it was one thing to offer a theological justification for the Catholic Church’s anti-Jewish prejudice that informed Pius actions and inactions and quite another to justify it morally.
Sitting next to Parolin, Di Segni rejected as offensive to Jews any judgements that are “absolutist and apologetic at all costs.”
veryGood! (26714)
Related
- Todd Golden to continue as Florida basketball coach despite sexual harassment probe
- Off the Grid: Sally breaks down USA TODAY's daily crossword puzzle, Last Try
- Look: Texas' Arch Manning throws first college football touchdown pass in blowout of CSU
- NASCAR Cup race at Darlington: Reddick wins regular season, Briscoe takes Darlington
- Jelly Roll goes to jail (for the best reason) ahead of Indianapolis concert
- Yellow lights are inconsistent and chaotic. Here's why.
- Gilmore Girls' Kelly Bishop Reacts to Criticism of Rory Gilmore's Adult Storyline
- Klamath River flows free after the last dams come down, leaving land to tribes and salmon
- Katharine Hayhoe’s Post-Election Advice: Fight Fear, Embrace Hope and Work Together
- Suspect, 15, arrested in shooting near Ohio high school that killed 1 teen, wounded 4
Ranking
- Police capture Tennessee murder suspect accused of faking his own death on scenic highway
- Murder on Music Row: Nashville couple witness man in ski mask take the shot. Who was he?
- Watch this smart pup find her owner’s mom’s grave with ease despite never meeting her
- Is Usha Vance’s Hindu identity an asset or a liability to the Trump-Vance campaign?
- Timothée Chalamet Details How He Transformed Into Bob Dylan for Movie
- What restaurants are open on Labor Day? Hours and details for McDonald's, Chick-fil-A, more
- Tyrese opens up about '1992' and Ray Liotta's final role: 'He blessed me'
- Here are the average Social Security benefits at retirement ages 62, 67, and 70
Recommendation
-
Kansas basketball vs Michigan State live score updates, highlights, how to watch Champions Classic
-
NCAA blocks Oklahoma State use of QR code helmet stickers for NIL fund
-
Brittany Cartwright Explains Why She Filed for Divorce From Jax Taylor
-
Is the stock market open or closed on Labor Day? See full 2024 holiday schedule
-
Anti-abortion advocates press Trump for more restrictions as abortion pill sales spike
-
What restaurants are open on Labor Day? Hours and details for McDonald's, Chick-fil-A, more
-
Sinaloa drug kingpin sentenced to 28 years for trafficking narcotics to Alaska
-
Defending champion Coco Gauff loses in the U.S. Open’s fourth round to Emma Navarro